Registering and logging in removes this ad.
Registering and logging in removes this ad.
Recommendations on USB Microphones
Submitted by Roy on Mon, 09/05/2005 - 14:10.
Hi,
Any recommendations on relatively inexpensive USB microphones? I'm not happy with the results I'm getting with my current mic, which uses the sound card, and would really appreciate any help on finding a USB alternative.
Thanks,
Roy


Roy,
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Any recommendations on relatively inexpensive USB microphones?
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
There is actually no such thing as a USB microphone. All microphones are analog and that they take Sure sound waves and hence these down a cable as an electrical impulse. It is the soundcard or a USB sound pod (just an external USB soundcard) that converts the analog signal to a digital format. The problems most people have with poor sound input is that the sound chip is not well insulated or shielded and thus picks up electronic noise from within the computer enclosure
The least expensive USB microphone is the Andrea NC-7100. This microphone will work OK in a quiet environment. If you are doing light-duty dictation like e-mails and simple letters it may work perfectly fine for you in a quiet environment. If you are doing more professional work and require better accuracy, consider an Andrea ANC microphone with an Andrea USB sound pod or a VXI TalkPro microphone with a VXI USB pod. Here are some links:
http://www.emicrophones.com/microphones/prod_detai... (NC-7100)
http://www.emicrophones.com/microphones/prod_detai... (ANC 700)
http://www.emicrophones.com/microphones/prod_detai... (Andrea USB pod)
http://www.emicrophones.com/microphones/prod_detai... (VXI TalkPro Xpress)
http://www.emicrophones.com/microphones/prod_detai... (VXI USB pod)
Martin Markoe, eMicrophones, Inc.
The best microphones for Speech Recognition
See us at: http://www.eMicrophones.com/index.asp
Read, "Key Steps to High Speech Recognition Accuracy" at:
http://www.emicrophones.com/docDetails.asp?Documen...
What Marty says is true. All
What Marty says is true. All microphones are analog it's just their interface that may be USB. So with a USB Pod (Andrea is a good one) you can make any microphone that would plug into a sound card a USB Microphone. The ones that say USB microphone merely have only that interface option. A better way is to get a USB pod and a good microphone. It gives the best of both worlds.
I have two microphones that I use this way. One is the Andrea ANC-600. The only thing I wish it had was two headphones so I could listen to music. It has a quick disconnect which can be good and bad. Good because you can unhook quick, bad because sometimes it doesn't like to go back together very well. Once you battle it back in place then it's ok. There's a mute switch too that I keep forgetting is turned to on (and muting the microphone). It's a fairly good noise cancelling microphone.
The other is a Sennheiser ME-3. This one has no quick disconnect or mute switch. It just works and does that well. It has no earphones at all, just a microphone and fits behind the head and over the ears. It will only work on the right hand side of your head as it can't be flipped over. I think this is the most intense microphone of the two. It's not cheap, but you can be in a lot of noise and this mic just ignores it. So I'd say they have a pretty directional microphone in it. If you get this one, it has to be modified for PC use. Not sure why, but it has to be. I know Marty modifies his so you don't have to worry. You'd also want to get an extension cable with it. Then you have a quick disconnect and mute of sorts.
I have a third microphone that I bought when I first got into SR. It's an Emkay something. I never managed to get it to work very well. It requires a different voice range or bigger lungs. Never was very happy with it as it never performed well. It also is VERY sensitive to RF interference.
The other thing I have in my PC audio array is an Andrea MC-100 Multimedia Control Switch. It's a little gray box that allows me to switch between speakers and the headset(or headphones) . It makes it easy to connect/disconnect microphones/headsets/headphones and even speakers without having to wrestle around behind the computer. It has a headset volume knob and the APS-100 auxiliary power supply (never had to use this but it's there) built into it.
Roy wrote:Hi, Any
Hi,
Any recommendations on relatively inexpensive USB microphones? I'm not happy with the results I'm getting with my current mic, which uses the sound card, and would really appreciate any help on finding a USB alternative.
Thanks,
Roy
Roy;
Marty Markoe's site at e-computing.com provides a good selection of proven microphones. If you think the problem is your sound card you might try replacing it with a USB pod that plugs into a USB port and your microphone then plugs into it. This often solves problems with electrically noisy computers perhaps laptops. It also provides the opportunity to use a wide choice of mikes.
You don't give us any information about your present set up. If you care to do this you may get more informed replies from the group.
Tim.
Tim,
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Marty Markoe's site at e-computing.com provides a good selection of proven microphones.
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
Thanks for the kind words. Our web site is at http://www.emicrophones.com.
Marty
Agree on the site but wonder
Agree on the site but wonder if you've misled Roy -- this forum is labeled "Desktop Mounted". So give him links to a selection of desktops.
Bruce
Marty and Roy; My apologies
Marty and Roy;
My apologies to both! Must have been out in the Labour Day sun too long.
Tim.
As others have said, a USB
As others have said, a USB pod (I'm using an Andrea, can't seem to find a model number - just says "USB Adapter") is great. I'm using a "Verbatim" headset mic (can't find a model designation), with headphones that enclose the ears. $29.95 Australian. Not particularly hi-fi phones, but the mic does a great job. Since I had the computer constructed with SR in mind, I spent a lot of money on the "soundcard" and there seems to be very little difference between USB and soundcard plugin. So essentially the "cheap" microphone with the USB pod seems to be as good as the cheap microphone into a good soundcard.
The other headset is also "Verbatim" but with rubber pads only, which I use for my "portable" recording/transcription set up. That plugs into a "VXI Translator" (Parrot) USB pod and does a sufficient job as well. The cheaper headphones were about $20 or so.
Joe
Joeblake1 wrote:As others
As others have said, a USB pod (I'm using an Andrea, can't seem to find a model number - just says "USB Adapter") is great. I'm using a "Verbatim" headset mic (can't find a model designation), with headphones that enclose the ears. $29.95 Australian. Not particularly hi-fi phones, but the mic does a great job. Since I had the computer constructed with SR in mind, I spent a lot of money on the "soundcard" and there seems to be very little difference between USB and soundcard plugin. So essentially the "cheap" microphone with the USB pod seems to be as good as the cheap microphone into a good soundcard.
The other headset is also "Verbatim" but with rubber pads only, which I use for my "portable" recording/transcription set up. That plugs into a "VXI Translator" (Parrot) USB pod and does a sufficient job as well. The cheaper headphones were about $20 or so.
Joe
Folks,
I think it's important to keep in mind a couple of things about the differences between sound cards and USB pods, or USB microphones.
First of all, whether you use a soundcard or USB pod/microphone, performance depends upon the DSP chip used in either. It also depends upon the microphone that you're using. A high-quality microphone with a high-quality sound card will produce equally as good a set of results in terms of accuracy and performance as any USB alternative.
Second, the assumption that USB is better than microphone/soundcard in terms of performance and accuracy is simply not demonstrated by the research. Again, it all depends upon the quality of the DSP chip that used, as well as the underlying supporting hardware. More importantly, a poor quality microphone will give you less than optimal results regardless of whether you use a soundcard or USB pod/microphone. It is performance that counts, and performance starts with a good microphone and ends with a good digital signal processing component. Products may differ, but from a purely technical standpoint with everything being equal, there is no significant difference between the use of a microphone and a soundcard vs. a microphone and a USB input device.
You get what you pay for, or at least if you buy quality, you'll get quality regardless of which approach you use.
Chuck Runquist
Phillips Speech Mikes These
Phillips Speech Mikes
These are more expensive, but generally are regarded as extremely good for general SR dictation.
For a lengthy documents which require holding the microphone up for any length of time, I avoid arm tiredness by using Marty's Balanced Arm, coupled with the Speechmike holder which I designed (and use) attached to the Balanced Arm (which can be seen at http://www.speechcomputing.com/node/167) which just requires a plastic sheet, a scissors and some heat to manufacture it. (Nobody has taken me up to produce a commercial version.
)
The advantage of the Speechmike is that it behaves like an ordinary dictating machine microphone, with 8 programmable buttons and a track ball. For example, I have buttons which I programmed to toggle the microphone on-and-off, backspace, forwardspace, and etc.
I have both the USB and the serial port versions. I use the USB with my laptop. I use the serial port (required for the trackball and programmable buttons) with my desktop into a SoundBlaster Live soundcard (cheapest version about three years ago) and the quality of recognition from both is almost identically excellent. The advantage of the serial version is that it has a curly lead, so it does not get entangled with my feet, or any other part of my anatomy
, and both versions come with a desk clip to attach to the edge of a desk (or even the edge of a laptop if there is space).
Quentin